Written By: Sara Beth
Do These Theories Hold Up, Or Nah?

Do These Theories Hold Up, Or Nah?
Remember when cartoons were all about fun, laughter, and colorful adventures? Turns out, some fans have been busy turning those innocent memories into wild, mind-bending theories. From sinister secrets to unexpected connections, these ideas will completely change how you see your favorite 90s cartoons. Buckle up—this ride gets weird!

Bender Became a Criminal Thanks to Fry

Bender Became a Criminal Thanks to Fry
Before Fry entered the picture, Bender was just another robot working his bending job. But according to this theory, Fry’s carefree, troublemaking ways led Bender down the path to crime. From robbing banks to bending the rules (literally), it seems like Fry might be the real bad influence. Who’s the real troublemaker here?

Mr. Krabs’ Disturbing Secret

Mr. Krabs’ Disturbing Secret
Ever wonder why Mr. Krabs is the only crab in Bikini Bottom—and what happened to Pearl’s mom? Some fans think the answer is horrifying: Mr. Krabs may have killed her and used her meat for Krabby Patties. Yes, you read that right. It’s an unsettling theory that makes you think twice about those “delicious” burgers.

 Homer Simpson Has Been in a Coma for Years

Homer Simpson Has Been in a Coma for Years
What if everything we’ve seen on The Simpsons since Season 4 is all a dream? This theory claims that Homer fell into a coma after a freak accident and that every bizarre storyline since then has been a figment of his imagination. From Springfield’s ageless characters to increasingly surreal plots, it all starts to make eerie sense.

Angelica Imagines the Babies

Angelica Imagines the Babies
What if the Rugrats babies never existed? According to this theory, Angelica made them up as a way to cope with her loneliness. Each baby supposedly represents a different part of her personality. This dark twist flips the lighthearted cartoon into a tragic story about a girl searching for connection.

Nurse Joy Might Be a Pokémon

Nurse Joy Might Be a Pokémon
How does Nurse Joy manage to be in every Pokémon Center, looking exactly the same? Fans have an answer: she’s a Pokémon! It explains her identical appearance, tireless energy, and ability to be everywhere at once. Suddenly, the Pokémon world makes a lot more sense.

Samurai Jack and Professor Utonium Are the Same Person

Samurai Jack and Professor Utonium Are the Same Person
This fan theory suggests Samurai Jack and The Powerpuff Girls share more than an art style. The idea? Jack eventually becomes Professor Utonium after failing to save his timeline. To continue his fight against evil, he creates the Powerpuff Girls. It’s a wild connection, but somehow, it feels just right.

SpongeBob and the Seven Deadly Sins

SpongeBob and the Seven Deadly Sins
Have you noticed how each SpongeBob SquarePants character has an exaggerated personality? This theory claims each one represents a deadly sin: Squidward is wrath, Patrick is sloth, Mr. Krabs is greed, and SpongeBob is lust (for life, of course). It’s a strange but oddly fitting take on Bikini Bottom’s quirky crew.

The Magic School Bus Kids Became Eco-Warriors

The Magic School Bus Kids Became Eco-Warriors
Miss Frizzle’s lessons might have been preparing her students for something bigger. According to this theory, her adventurous class grew up to become the Planeteers from Captain Planet. Their personalities match perfectly, and it’s easy to imagine Arnold, Phoebe, and the gang taking on a mission to save the world.

Bobby Hill’s Real Dad

Bobby Hill’s Real Dad
Could Bobby Hill actually be Bill Dauterive’s son? Fans have noticed that Bobby shares Bill’s softer personality, round face, and lack of Hank’s trademark stubbornness. If this theory is true, it would add a whole new level of awkwardness to Thanksgiving dinners at the Hill house.

Ed, Edd n Eddy Are Trapped in Purgatory

Ed, Edd n Eddy Are Trapped in Purgatory
Why are there no adults in Ed, Edd n Eddy? According to this theory, the kids are stuck in purgatory, and the cul-de-sac is their eternal playground. Each child represents a different decade of youth culture, making the show a creepy and symbolic take on childhood.

Chief Wiggum and His Wife Are Siblings

Chief Wiggum and His Wife Are Siblings
Springfield has always been a little… off, but this theory takes it to another level. Fans believe Chief Wiggum and his wife Sarah are actually siblings. Their similar features—and Ralph’s unique personality—are offered as proof. It’s weird and uncomfortable, but in a town like Springfield, anything is possible.